Presentation Information
[HC-XN3Qv-12]Friction Performance of Hot Mix Asphalt with Limestone and Silicious Aggregates after 1-Million Laboratory Polishing Cycles
*Phillip B Blankenship1, Stephen Goodman2 (1. Blankenship Asphalt Tech and Training (USA), 2. Goodman Pavement and Materials Engineering (Canada))
Keywords:
friction,polishing,DFT,TWPD,accelerated
Each year, approximately 40,000 people die in motor vehicle crashes on US roadways – an incredible number even with a population of almost 342 million. North of the 49th parallel, approximately 2,000 Canadian motorists perish annually even with greatly fewer inhabitants. Adopted by many countries including the US and Canada, “Vision Zero” acknowledges that even a single death on the transportation system is unacceptable and focusses on safe mobility for all. As a proven, cross-cutting safety countermeasure for reducing the frequency and severity of vehicle crashes, Pavement Friction Management (PFM) provides road agencies with a powerful tool for balancing the existing roadway friction with that required by vehicles to navigate the road network. Managing pavement friction has been shown to directly reduce vehicle crash rates in the US and Canada on average of 30 percent across all roadway facilities.
As both initial and long-term friction performance are required to minimize vehicle crashes, Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) should incorporate aggregates that resist long-term polishing effort by vehicles. Historically, many road agencies have identified sources of polish-resistant aggregates from legacy data or multi-year monitoring efforts. However, as these legacy sources are depleted, new sources will be required, and long-term assessment approaches used in the past may no longer be feasible.
To accelerate the evaluation process, the use of the NCAT Three-Wheel Polishing Device (TWPD) and Dynamic Friction Tester (DFT) offers a promising laboratory approach. At present, NCAT recommends 150,000 cycles in the TWPD to assess the polish resistance of aggregates in compacted HMA samples. The test is tortuous – with three polishing tires at 87 psi turning on the wetted HMA surface. As an exercise, extended TWPD up to 1,000,000 cycles was utilized to compare the polish resistance of multiple HMA mixtures produced with varying percentages of two different aggregate sources.
The results were interesting – although the HMA produced with silica-based aggregates started with slightly lower friction values than the HMA produced with dolomite limestone, it maintained the friction longer – i.e. the silica-based aggregates had greater polish resistance after 1 million polishing cycles. However, this was not apparent at the recommended 150,000 polishing cycles - the limestone HMA had greater friction as measured with the DFT until approximately 200,000 polishing cycles. The slope of the DFT friction versus the number of polishing cycles curve appears to have promise for identifying aggregate polish resistance and should be considered during the evaluation process.
The study also provided insights into the use of Acid Insoluble Residue (AIR) testing, which is a common requirement by many road agencies. More specifically, it was determined that while AIR is effective for assessing the durability of the dolomite limestone, it was not as suitable for the silicious aggregate. It was therefore recommended to use AIR as an index test to be reported but waived if the TWPD and DFT results were acceptable.
While routine TWPD polishing to 1 million cycles is not recommended due to excessive time and machine wear, the results did suggest that long-term polishing performance of aggregates is complex. Overall, the use of the TWPD and DFT in the laboratory presents a promising approach for the accelerated evaluation of HMA mixtures and new aggregate sources, with the ultimate goal of better managing pavement friction and saving lives on US and Canadian roadways.
As both initial and long-term friction performance are required to minimize vehicle crashes, Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) should incorporate aggregates that resist long-term polishing effort by vehicles. Historically, many road agencies have identified sources of polish-resistant aggregates from legacy data or multi-year monitoring efforts. However, as these legacy sources are depleted, new sources will be required, and long-term assessment approaches used in the past may no longer be feasible.
To accelerate the evaluation process, the use of the NCAT Three-Wheel Polishing Device (TWPD) and Dynamic Friction Tester (DFT) offers a promising laboratory approach. At present, NCAT recommends 150,000 cycles in the TWPD to assess the polish resistance of aggregates in compacted HMA samples. The test is tortuous – with three polishing tires at 87 psi turning on the wetted HMA surface. As an exercise, extended TWPD up to 1,000,000 cycles was utilized to compare the polish resistance of multiple HMA mixtures produced with varying percentages of two different aggregate sources.
The results were interesting – although the HMA produced with silica-based aggregates started with slightly lower friction values than the HMA produced with dolomite limestone, it maintained the friction longer – i.e. the silica-based aggregates had greater polish resistance after 1 million polishing cycles. However, this was not apparent at the recommended 150,000 polishing cycles - the limestone HMA had greater friction as measured with the DFT until approximately 200,000 polishing cycles. The slope of the DFT friction versus the number of polishing cycles curve appears to have promise for identifying aggregate polish resistance and should be considered during the evaluation process.
The study also provided insights into the use of Acid Insoluble Residue (AIR) testing, which is a common requirement by many road agencies. More specifically, it was determined that while AIR is effective for assessing the durability of the dolomite limestone, it was not as suitable for the silicious aggregate. It was therefore recommended to use AIR as an index test to be reported but waived if the TWPD and DFT results were acceptable.
While routine TWPD polishing to 1 million cycles is not recommended due to excessive time and machine wear, the results did suggest that long-term polishing performance of aggregates is complex. Overall, the use of the TWPD and DFT in the laboratory presents a promising approach for the accelerated evaluation of HMA mixtures and new aggregate sources, with the ultimate goal of better managing pavement friction and saving lives on US and Canadian roadways.
